Islamorada Fish Company - Seafood|Bar & Grill|American Type Restaurant in Myrtle Beach Mall with 80 reviews

Islamorada Fish Company

Seafood, Bar & Grill, American Restaurant in Myrtle Beach Mall

 
Islamorada Fish Company
Rated: 0 out of 5 with 80 Reviews

Islamorada means "Purple Isle". This is very popular seafood and sushi restaurant located at the Myrtle Beach Mall. Now operated by the Bass Pro shops, the orgins of this restaurant go back to 1907 when it was a family business in the Florida Keys.


Islamorada Fish Company
10177 North Kings Hwy.
Myrtle Beach Mall
843-361-4700
Hours: Monday-Saturday 11a-9p. Sunday 11a-6p
General Info:
  • Lunch Served
  • Dinner Served
  • Snacks or Appetizers
  • Outdoor Seating
  • MBP discount card accepted
There are currently 80 user submitted reviews for this restaurant.

Reviews of Islamorada Fish Company

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Apr 14th, 2016 at 8:08 am
From: Myrtle Beach, SOUTH CAROLINA
By: ls


Avg. Rating:3
A Very nice atmosphere, nice decoration. Everything else very poor. The gator didn´t taste gator it was too spicy, too salty and actually was covered with terrible too thick breadcrumbs glaze. The only thing that you tasted was the spices. Why not just grilled the gator?? The catfish didn´t taste at all and was totally covered with fried garlic. Even if you tried to take them away the taste was absolutely too strong. If you wanna eat good FRESH food why to hide them under spices and covers? The waitress was talking, talking, talking ... what she did or where she wants to go and she she she ... after every 5 minutes she came to ask is everything ok and kept on doing that too often. She enplaned us what to have dessert after 10 minutes we got the main food. The bill we need to fix twice. Sorry, but won´t recommend that to anybody. We didn´t like the food and the service at all.
ref: 28112
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Aug 21st, 2011 at 8:30 pm
From: Powell, OH
By: km


Avg. Rating:4.3
Great food, reasonably priced, and great staff. We will be back again!
ref: 23747
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Aug 07th, 2011 at 3:05 pm
From: Myrtle Beach, SC
By: km


Avg. Rating:4.2
So glad to see you have Greg at the sushi bar now - definitely an asset to Islamorada. We will be visiting alot now that Greg is there.
ref: 23607
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Sep 05th, 2010 at 2:52 pm
From: Charleston, SC
By: nd


Avg. Rating:5
We had a great time! The servers are SUPER friendly. Everyone in the restaurant appears to enjoy their job and they are all so nice. We tried the alligator tail--excellent! The sauce for dipping the alligator in was excellent too, some kind of jalapeno/cream cheese jelly. Sounds nasty, but it was awesome! The free bread is wonderful, and our server even brought us an extra loaf to take home. We will definitely be returning to this restaurant, even if it's just a day trip to go there and come back home!
ref: 20606
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Jul 05th, 2010 at 7:33 pm
From: Myrtle Beach, SC
By: mh


Avg. Rating:3
Seated at dirty table. Waited over 15 minutes for a waiter/waitress, then we had to find the manager just to be moved to a clean table and have our drink orders taken then waited for our drinks and appetizers... needless to say VERY BAD EXPERIENCE
ref: 19636
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: May 06th, 2010 at 11:27 am
From: HAGERSTOWN, MD
By: gwc


Avg. Rating:5
The women were shopping so we decided just to get a little something to eat. The sushi was great and the manager brought out hot bread free that we didnt even ask for. The sushi was so good went back later that week and double our order . Some of the sushi was half price and they had a special on the steak that my wife loved. I ask for gift card for Christmas for this year.
ref: 18941
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Jul 13th, 2009 at 10:29 pm
From: Asheville, NC
By: jmc


Avg. Rating:4.8
I have been going to the Islamorada Fish Co. for years including this one at Myrtle Beach and the one in Sevierville, TN and I have NOTHING bad to say about it. I finally got my wife to go with me on our last trip to Myrtle Beach and she has already said it is a "must go there" for our trip next month. The only reason I did not rank it a straight exellent is for the following reasons. 1. Atmostphere - I rated it above average and the only reason I didn't rate it as excellant is because the only way in or out of the restaurant is through Bass Pro Shop (there are entrances leading directly to the parking lot but every time I have been there they are locked) . Even though I have a deep seated love for the store, it is a bother that their time share sales desk is located almost directy in front of the main isle as you leave the restuarant. I can tell you that even though they are more polite than most, just like all the time share sales people they dont mind interupting conversations to get your attention and can sometimes be hard to get away from. 2. Value for the money - the food is great, I've only had one bad meal there. Keep in mind, it was my first time trying talapia, and as I later found out, I simply dont like that particular fish. But I can tell you the grouper, catfish, and chicken dishes are absolutely fantastic. Havent tried their burgers yet. The only reason it didnt rate an exellent with me is I feel in order to rate it as that I would almost feel as if I got more than my moneys worth... but I can say you do get what you pay for at this restaurant, not complaining but the price does evenly match the quality. Still you wont be disappointed.
ref: 16002
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Jun 29th, 2009 at 12:46 pm
From: Waxhaw North Carolina, NC
By: pc


Avg. Rating:4.3
Awesome Restaurant. You have to try either their Grouper Sandwich or Hamburgers. We came last year with a Friend from Charlotte NC and loved it. Came back this year and had the same Great Experience.
ref: 15757
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Jun 14th, 2009 at 8:50 pm
From: Maryville, TN
By: lh


Avg. Rating:3.7
We have visited Islamorada twice this week. Wednesday was great!!! Food, service, length of time for ordering to finishing the meal was super...... Sunday the food (when it arrived was great) Now the bad news, DON'T go on a Sunday night. Not enough waiters/ waitresses to serve.We arrived at 7:00, seated very quickly. It took unitl 7:15 to order drinks, 7:25 to get them. The meal did not arrive until 7:55. SOMETHING is wrong with that. I don't know what the problem was but it was a problem. Suggestions: 1) go before the rush, 2) if there are a lot of children or the place is more that half full---turn around and come another night.
ref: 15477
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Apr 27th, 2009 at 1:38 pm
From: Conyers, GA
By: ckn


Avg. Rating:5
When I went to the restaurant I was immediately greeted by the hostess. She was nice and took me and my party to a table immediately. The menu had a fantastic choice of items to choose from. The server was there within a minute of us sitting and was very knowledgable about the menu. She was also very polite.We ordered and got the food quicker than I would expect for such a nice restaurant. Also, the food was GREAT!. I had a tuna wasabi that was to die for. Even the bill was not that much. All in all we had a great experience
ref: 14751
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Mar 22nd, 2009 at 8:44 pm
From: Lambertville, MI
By: pe


Avg. Rating:4.7
My husband and I tried this restaurant on a whim. We absolutely loved it! We had oysters and the steamed shrimp for appetizers which were excellent. My husband then had the grilled/blackened combo basket (scallops and grouper) which he raved about. I was not sure what to try but the waitress was a very big help and offered her suggestions. I finally settled on sushi. This sushi was absolutely fantastic and I loved it as much as the sushi I get from a sushi restaurant at home. I had the dragon roll at my waitress' suggestion and am happy I did. The bread was wonderful, the wait staff was top notch and I cannot say enough good things about the overall experience. Definitely would go back when visiting this area!
ref: 14317
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Mar 07th, 2009 at 7:58 am
From: Myrtle Beach, SC
By: l.a.


Avg. Rating:4.7
Since there are such mixed reviews on this site I wanted to add my two cents. The beach roll (sushi) was excellent, the coconut crusted shrimp appetizer was very good, my husband liked his fried allegator bites, the bread was good, but the lettuce in the salad was a bit rubbery. Service was very attentive. We will definitely go back - especially when we're in the mood for sushi..
ref: 14156
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Feb 15th, 2009 at 10:53 am
From: Hallandale Beach, , FLORIDA
By: w.a.


Avg. Rating:3.8
We picked those ratings from experience that we had in other restaurants. We were taken to this restaurant by our children who have dined there 4 times before. We had a very lovely dining experience last night and will look forward to enjoying this restaurant again. W.A.
ref: 13952
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Feb 01st, 2009 at 12:00 pm
From: winterville, NC
By: dm


Avg. Rating:4.2
Was a little worried about the high prices but it was worth it. I had fried lobster stuffed with shrimp and it was awesome! also got the alligator bites and they were good but the green sauce served with them was not good. I ended up with coctail sauce and that was much better. Slaw was disappointed but everything else was good. Will go again but only if they have the fried lobster again.
ref: 13793
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Islamorada Fish Company
Posted: Aug 30th, 2008 at 6:19 pm
From: Little River, SC
By: bb


Avg. Rating:2.3
All I have to say calamari that taste like chicken tenders and looks like a pile of grease
ref: 12643
Review Separator