Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1

Seafood Restaurant in Myrtle Beach

Reviews of Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:

Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Nov 08th, 2007 at 9:05 am From: Woodbridge, VA By: raj Avg. Rating:3.7

My family has enjoyed Benjamin's for a number of years as we are devoted crab leg eaters. The prices are probably the higest in the area so we always take advantage of the Early Bird discounts with coupons. Unfortunately on our last visit we had a bad experience with a gift certificate we from received from friends. The certificate was purchased from Benjamin's and paid for in full (no discount). We showed the Hostess the certificate and gave our Early Bird Discount coupon to her and was tld that we couldn't use both "coupons". I tried to explain that the gift certificate was not a coupon and was paid for at face value. They said the owner's policy was that you can't receive a discount when using a gift certificate. So long, story short -- don't buy gift certificates for anyone because it will cost more in the long run. ref: 9184

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:

Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Nov 05th, 2007 at 11:39 am From: Olathe, KS By: dj Avg. Rating:3.2

After reading that this was #1 seafood buffet in Myrtle Beach the wife and I were very disappointed. We came on a Sunday night around 8 pm. We were seated immediately after being given a tour of the buffet by the hostess. Even though it was still early in the evening the dishes on the buffet looked like they had been sitting there for days. The fish was dried out, the vegetables were limp. The dessert bar was a mess. I think the main problem was it was a slower night and there were still making large pans of all the entries. Even though we managed to find some good things to eat, overall it was very disappointing. Also the staff stood around and talked with each other. Several times customers had squeeze around them to get to the buffett. Save your money and eat at Pier 14. It is a much better restaurant. ref: 9148

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:

Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Sep 11th, 2007 at 9:53 pm From: Eden, NC By: ji Avg. Rating:3

I looked forward to going to this restaurant but was disappointed from the time I walked in the front door. The place smelled musky. We were seated immediately but it took about 10 minutes for our server to show up, and it was not even at a busy time. I agree with another person, the restaurant seems to concentrate on quanity rather than quality. I will not return to this restaurant. It is pricey and below average for a restaurant, period. ref: 8227

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:	Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Sep 05th, 2007 at 8:00 pm From: Cincinnati, OH By: cv Avg. Rating:3.7
This was my first and last time at Benjamin's. I've been to Myrtle Beach over thirty times, yet never been to a Benjamin's. I went for the first time in August 2007, I will not be going back in September 2007 when I'm back down there. The food was so-so, and the atmosphere was horrible. ref: 8115

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:

Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Aug 25th, 2007 at 5:30 pm From: Charlotte, NC By: ss Avg. Rating:4.7

Hello traveling vacation clan. I'm a business exec, live in Charlotte, N.C. and have been vacationing in Myrtle Beach since I was a wee lad. I'm a big boy now with a little one of my own and as far back as I can remember, and since the 1rst time a local told me where to eat the best buffet in town bar none, Benjamins has been THE place to eat for a seafood/misc buffet. Anyone posting that tells you otherwise simply is guiding you astray or perhaps needs to be eating at venue or ethnic specific establishment because when it comes to variety and doing it well, there is no close second to Benjamin's on restaurant row and trust me because I have tried most of them all. Some may be $5.00 or so cheaper and if that makes you or breaks you than take advantage of the early bird special. Either way do yourself a favor, go in anywhere else and look at what they have and then just take a quick walk and look inside Benjamins and you will see that it's money very well spent for the difference. All the food is very good and fresh but the king crab legs...AWESOME fresh, hot and abundant everytime. A trip to Myrtle Beach without a stop or two at Benjamins is a trip with something missing. Treat yourself, go to Benjamins, get a seat with a waterway view and experience what true southern Iced Tea and authentic Myrtle Beach seafood plus dining is all about. Bon Apetit y'all! ref: 7852

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:

Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Aug 16th, 2007 at 8:12 pm From: Winchester, TN By: ss Avg. Rating:3.2

The curb appeal of this restaurant is excellent, enticing one to stop. The staff is personable and a true asset to the establishment. There was a sour smell throughout the restaurant. It made us wonder about cleanliness. We did not appreciate the cost of the meal, even though the variety was there, you can only eat so much. One plate and a dessert was plenty. We were paying for the gluttons to have their fill. ref: 7651

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:	Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Aug 16th, 2007 at 5:57 pm From: Milwaukee, WI By: mcq Avg. Rating:3.3
We really liked the soft drinks... They were very refreshing. ref: 7648

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:

Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Aug 13th, 2007 at 10:59 am From: Pittsburgh, PA By: mak Avg. Rating:3.5

If you're looking for an all-you-can-eat place, this the restaurant to try. With 170 choices, it's hard to beat. My family loves the food here and it satisfies the men in my family. For me, I think that for $27/person, it's a bit pricey and I can't eat that much but if you have a big appetite, you've found your Mecca. My sons love crab legs and shrimp, especially the spicy shrimp. The made-to-order pasta is also a plus. ref: 7579

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:

Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Aug 07th, 2007 at 6:47 pm From: Conwway-Wildwood, SC-NJ By: rb Avg. Rating:2.7

My significant other and I have eating here on many occasions over the years. Today was a big disappointment. The best part was our very nice waitress " Donna". She tried her best with linted resources .The buss boys were so noisy in their cleaning of tables ,you would thought they were having a race. I do believe they were playing games. I asked if this establishment changed hand since our last visit May of 2007 and was told it had not. The food was scarce and so were the plates. They ran out of horseradish, so one had to make do with the water down cocktail sause.Can you imagine a big seafood menu and someone forgets to order cocktail sauce? The crab legs were overcooked and difficult to get meat from. The BBQ ribs were undercooked and very tough. No cups for after dinner coffee.Someone is really dropping the ball on what has been ,time and time again a four star rating in my book. Today was one star at best ref: 7476

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:	Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Aug 07th, 2007 at 12:35 pm From: Pineville, WV By: tl Avg. Rating:2.8
Too pricey for the quality of food and service. The crab legs were a little stringier than we liked. The service was horrid. Our waitress was among the worst we've ever received. ref: 7469

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:	Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Jul 31st, 2007 at 7:47 pm From: Pittsburgh, PA By: sap Avg. Rating:2.3
Unable to seat a large party together. Food is average. Even after a 15% gratuity added in to your bill the waitresses expect to keep the change and all they do is bring you drinks. Buffet is crowed and you wait in lines often to come upon empty trays. Price is a slap in the face for what you get in food, atmosphere and service. ref: 7353

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:	Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: May 09th, 2007 at 7:53 pm From: Myrtle Beach, SC By: sb Avg. Rating:3.3
Our first experience at this restaurant left us disappointed. The food was plentiful but tasted very average except the crab legs and the pulled pork which were excellent. The service was great, we were seated immediately as were went when they first opened. If you love all you can eat crablegs the value is ok, otherwise the price is hefty. ref: 5762

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:

Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Sep 06th, 2006 at 9:15 am From: Sharon Springs, NY By: gn Avg. Rating:5

The Original Benjamin's Clabash Seafood Restaurant is cavernous, kitschy and cool. The food is incredible and amazingly fresh, not a small feat for a place big enough to have its own zip code and offering so many varieties of foods. Unlike other reviewers, the inclusion of foods other than seafood on the menu was appreciated by some in our party, particularly children. The mixed drinks are delightful, and don't pass on the dessert bar or you'll regret it. Staff was wonderfully efficient, friendly, and doesn't smother you with unwanted attention in the middle of your meal. Benjamin's Calabash should have its own star on a map of South Carolina. ref: 3760

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:	Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Aug 08th, 2006 at 9:40 pm From: BEALETON, VA. By: rc-dc Avg. Rating:5
We visited benjamin's last summer (2005) and cannot say enough about the quality of the food and service. We were seated as soon as we walked in... It has got to be one of the "best" seafood buffets in Myrtle Beach... We are planning our next visit to the beach and to again dine at Benjamins.. (Aug 2006). See you then!!!! ref: 3460

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:	Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Jul 03rd, 2006 at 12:31 pm From: Damascus, Md, MD By: acp Avg. Rating:5
Those fritters were the best as you walk in the door they hand your a basket to eat as you walk to the table. I had a lot of seafood while dining with you and I must say as a buffet it was great. I mostly had the crabs legs (My Fav) but you must understand, you don't offer all you can eat crabs legs to a guy like me. I found a home..Service was excellent.. ref: 2864

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:	Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Jun 19th, 2006 at 2:43 pm From: North Royalton (Cleveland), OH By: ms Avg. Rating:4.5
I have been going to this restaurant for over 14 years the service is always fantastic and the food is awesome. ref: 2714

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:	Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: May 12th, 2006 at 1:15 pm From: New Albany, INDIANA By: mjp Avg. Rating:5
The greatest restuarant in the world. They have everything you could want to eat and more. It is a little pricey but it is worth it. Coming back in June of 06 and i am bringing 2 new timers to the area. This will be the first place i take them to eat. ref: 2417

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:	Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: May 07th, 2006 at 3:27 pm From: princeton, WV By: rm Avg. Rating:4.7
This is the best seafood buffet of all Myrtle Beach restaurants. It is not cheap, but you won't leave hungry. I visit them about 6 times a year and look forward to it every time. ref: 2368

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:	Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Feb 09th, 2006 at 9:49 pm From: Atlanta, GA By: lt Avg. Rating:3.8
Best meal of our visit. ref: 2005

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:

Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Jan 28th, 2006 at 8:51 pm From: Norwalk, OH By: ts Avg. Rating:3.3

Benjamin's Calabash Seafood is an enormous restaurant. There are more than enough staff to service the crowds even at maximum capacity. But when I see a sign that says "seafood buffet", that's what I expect. Yes, there are over 100 different items on the buffet, but not even 20% of that is seafood. It's totally misleading. Also, the quality of food is just horrible. They seem to be focused on quantity rather than quality. I've been there 5 times and it gets worse every year. I believe I've given them a fair chance. It's time to move on. ref: 1954

Food:   Service:   Atmosphere:   Value:   Seating:   Noise:	Benjamin's Calabash Seafood 1 Posted: Aug 17th, 2005 at 3:40 pm From: Cornelius, NC By: rjs Avg. Rating:4.7
DO NOT EAT FOR THREE DAYS before you go here I tell ya.... you will need all the space you can get for the 100's of tasty items on the food bars. The CRAB LEGS are always hot and delish....yum! I go every year and have for years... ref: 1105