Nico's of NY - Italian Type Restaurant in Garden City with 51 reviews

Nico's of NY

Italian Restaurant in Garden City

 
Nico's of NY
Rated: 3.9 out of 5 with 51 Reviews

Italian restaurant featuring a variety of dishes, real New York style pizza, and signature dish Tortellini alla Nico. Open for lunch 11:30am to 2:30pm; Early bird 3pm to 5pm; Dinner 5pm to 9:30pm. Monday through Saturday.


Nico's of NY
3030 Business 17
Garden City
843-651-1528
Hours: N/A
There are currently 51 user submitted reviews for this restaurant.

Reviews of Nico's of NY

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Dec 27th, 2012 at 5:10 pm
From: Myrtle Beach, SC
By: ar


Avg. Rating:3
Restaurant closed. Replaced by a store buying gold.
ref: 26232
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Jun 29th, 2012 at 10:20 pm
From: Socastee, SC
By: lh


Avg. Rating:5
Only one problem ... they are no longer in Garden City. Heard they have a place in Myrtle Beach, which we will have to find & try out.
ref: 25424
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: May 10th, 2012 at 4:40 pm
From: Myrtle Beach, SC
By: ar


Avg. Rating:3
This restaurant is closed.
ref: 25101
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Jan 31st, 2012 at 5:13 am
From: MURRELLS INLET, SC
By: lp


Avg. Rating:3
RESTAURANT HAS CLOSED
ref: 24565
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Sep 03rd, 2011 at 9:21 am
From: Garden City, SC
By: pja


Avg. Rating:4.5
Love Nico's but arrived in Myrtle Beach, headed to Nico's for dinner. Closed. Did they relocate or go out of business? Does anyone know?
ref: 23857
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Aug 20th, 2011 at 10:57 am
From: North Myrtle beach, , SC
By: sv


Avg. Rating:4
I've been going to Nico's for quite some time and have never been dissapointed. Robert goes out of his way to stop by and say Hello and to ask how our family is. He makes the best Sicillian Pizza I have ever had. We formerly lived in NY and I'm so happy there is a Nico's...
ref: 23734
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Aug 01st, 2011 at 2:49 pm
From: myrtle beach, SC
By: co


Avg. Rating:3
Just received a gift certificate,called the phone # and was told it was disconnected. Are they in a new location now??.
ref: 23537
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Feb 05th, 2011 at 7:09 pm
From: Surfside, SC
By: km


Avg. Rating:2.7
Stopped last night and had a coupon from the "Attractions Book". They would not honor it because we were told that it was printed as a mistake. (Buy 1 pizza ~ get 1 free).. Printed as a mistake? That is really a stupid statement as someone had to approve it as the book was printed last fall. We bought the pizza anyway, not the greatest, kind of chewey, but the important part is that they have lost 6 customers..It was 3 couples, (locals) that will not return.
ref: 21790
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Jan 06th, 2011 at 10:23 pm
From: Reading, PA
By: c a


Avg. Rating:4.8
Food is exelent service is great wait staff the best in Myrtle Beach area
ref: 21576
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Nov 08th, 2010 at 12:18 pm
From: NMB, SC
By: gsm


Avg. Rating:2.8
Restaurant was cute, nice little salad bar. Server was very attentive. I ordered Veal Saltimbaca. The flavor was so-so but the portion was very skimpy for the price. I was not able to really enjoy my meal due to the smell of smoke in the room and I was in the non-smoking section. Had to hurry my meal to get out to fresh air. Won't go there again, I'm afraid.
ref: 21214
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Oct 25th, 2010 at 8:09 pm
From: Buffalo, NY
By: rak


Avg. Rating:4
My husband and I have a Condo in Murrells Inlet and have tried many dishes that we loved. In Sept. 2010, four of my sisters and I came down from NY and I took them to Nico's. What a great evening we had, the food was excellent (all different entree) The service excellent and the wine. They can't wait to come back.
ref: 21136
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Sep 29th, 2010 at 4:18 pm
From: Turnersville, NJ
By: glm


Avg. Rating:4.8
Super !!!... Every year we return while on vacation, and they remember us !!! The staff couldn't be any nicer and the food is terrific. If you're looking for an awesome italian meal.. you must go !!!
ref: 20892
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Sep 25th, 2010 at 11:34 am
From: MURRELLS INLET, SC
By: sp


Avg. Rating:4.7
Best damn pizza on the beach. None comparable!.
ref: 20827
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Jun 24th, 2010 at 6:46 pm
From: Annandale, VA
By: map


Avg. Rating:4.8
We own a vacation home in Surfside and this is one of our regular stops for dinner. The pizza is outstanding the best in Myrtle and trust me I have tried most of them. The Sicilian is the best, the veggie excellent and using sliced sausage, well that is the best!. I have had several of the veal dishes, all suburb. Cannot comment on pasta, my Mom is Italian and usually we do not eat pasta/red sauce out.
ref: 19503
Review Separator

Food:
 
Service:
 
Atmosphere:
 
Value:
 
Seating:
 
Noise:
 
Nico's of NY
Posted: Jun 01st, 2010 at 2:03 pm
From: Myrtle Beach, SC
By: jm


Avg. Rating:2.5
During bike week I ( a regular - local) ordered take out and was VERY disappointed. One item ordered was an eggplant grinder. Based on the amount of eggplant they put in the sandwich I would guess they ran out, and I would have preferred that they told me that. I also PAID for a side of extra sauce and did not get it. I think their prices are getting a little high.
ref: 19181
Review Separator