|
Anthony's Pizza & Pan PastaPizza Restaurant in Surfside Beach
NY style pizza is the specialty along with great wings and huge pasta portions with tons of memorabilia on the walls. Full bar available. Voted Best Pizza on the Beach in 2003, and runner-up in 2004. Hours are Sunday-Thursday 11AM to 10PM; Friday and Saturday 11AM to 11PM.
There are currently 24 independent, user-submitted restaurant reviews for Anthony's Pizza & Pan Pasta.
Reviews of Anthony's Pizza & Pan Pasta
Posted:01-12-2010
| Food: |  |
| Service: |  |
| Atmosphere: |  |
| Value: | |
| Seating: |  |
| Noise: | |
Review: We have been going to Anthony's since moving here from Va seven years. Our neighbors used to operate it then sold their interest back two years ago to the original owner. Over all it has slipped somewhat since the change in management. It depends on who is cooking on the night you are there. The servers have turned over except for one and the new help are "no help"! Overall, we have only been dissappointed twice out of about about thirty visits.
Surfside Beach, South Carolina |
Posted:12-07-2009
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: Great Job on winning number #2 on the beach, right in between the chains wow with all those reviews on the bottom, sounds like some of us has issues, you would never had won if things were that bad, I hope it's not other business owners that try to ruin others businesses. Geat Job!!!!
Murells Inlet, South Carolina |
Posted:11-27-2009
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: I was born and raised in Ny.. I know good pizza.. THIS IS GOOD PIZZA!!!!!!!!!!! i dont know why there are negative reviews because on top of having good food the people are always nice and im sure if you didnt like it they would offer to fix or refund the order!!! So keep up the good work i need somewhere to get my pizza from in sc! Thanks
Medford, New York |
Posted:09-05-2009
| Food: |  |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: The food is outrageous. I was shocked about the pizza they served me, tasted cheap,factory dough with absolutely no quality. Lets not talk about the owner loud, annoying person, who got a big ego.
Altogether its a shame for italian cooking and a joke for restaurant.
Edison, New Jersy |
Posted:04-01-2009
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: I dont know what happenend to Anthony's but they have gone way down hill! There pizza used to be awesome, but now its aweful!
The last time my family was there, I ordered pasta with alfredo sauce and when I recieved it, I could hardly even see the alfredo sauce, not even enough to wrap the pasta around. When I mentioned this to the waitress, she just shrugged her shoulders and moved on....
Being a local, my family used to come here for pizza all the time....NOT ANYMORE!
Ssb, South Carolina |
Posted:03-08-2009
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: Were from Canada and spent the first week of march in myrtle beach.
After almost a full week of going to shows and sightseeing the second last day of our vacation we went on line and searched different restaurant's and found this site and buy the reviews that we seen we decided to try it well we were impressed we ordered a large white pizza (white=no tomato sauce) with red onion and marinated chicken. being from Canada where around ever corner there's a pizza pizza it was the best pizza we have ever had. the server was lori and she was very nice and service was fast the owner came out after our pizza and gave us an Italian pastry treat i can't remember the name he offered it to other tables as well we recommend Anthony's Pizza & Pan Pasta with 2 thumbs up's..
Toronto Canada, LO |
Posted:02-25-2009
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: Just a ripoff, lived here 15 years, from ny most of these restaurants think every customer is a "tourist" i've seen many places go out of business with that atitude, I realize they have a "dumb" workforce to choose from, you better teach them how to deal with your customers, or you'll be cooking for someone else's place! too "pricy" food not that good .
Surfside Beach, South Carolina |
Posted:12-28-2008
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: I, and my friends never understood the raves about this place. The only thing I would eat there is a pizza, and only IN the restaurant, if I had no other choice. Do not EVER order a pizza for delivery ...we live right across the street and ALWAYS had to call 2 or 3 times, to 'eventually' get the rubbery, cold thing after many calls and unexplainable confusion. Before we knew about the quality of the food - I orderd eggplant parm, it was breaded and served - - UNcooked...the chicken parm is hard crusty strips of (fast food chicken fingers?) hiding under five inches of cheese slathered over it. Watery, awful sauce...and I think they just don't care or 'get it'.
Surfside Beach, South Carolina |
Posted:12-09-2008
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: Don't waist your time. We live in Garden City SC takes about 15 minutes for us to drive to Anthony's and the times we had gone (friends talk us into it) we have had little to no contact with the waitstaff as they spent more time talking to each other or friends they had sitting at the bar. Our food order has never been correct yet.
We order delivery 3 times. The first time it was ok. The second time they never delievered the food we called our order in at 7:30 PM we called back 4 times each time we were told that our food was on the way. The last call we made was at 9:45 PM asking who was delievering our food and were told it had been and the driver was back. We then spoke to someone who claimed they delievered the food and they did not even know were they delievered it. The last time we ordered we did so to give them a chance, everyone has bad days. On the third and last time we ordered we recieved the wrong food and were charged for what we ordered. Our order was for 3 large pizzas, garlic knots, a salad and fried mushrooms, we received 3 small (looked like personal size pizzas) one salad and 3 empty boxes. We will never order or visit again.
Not to accuse anyone but it looked like someone eat the food they were to deliever on both the last to orders we made.
Garden City, South Carolina |
Posted:11-30-2008
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: We are locals who ordered pizza delivery from here. It was the WORSE pizza we had ever eaten. Threw the left-over out.
Murrells Inlet, South Carolina |
Posted:11-21-2008
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: The guy who wrote the last review is a butt sniffer. Why dont you grow up and find something better to do. It's not all about you man, and maybe that waitress liked that song that was playing, ever think about that! don't be so self centered!.
Hudson, Wisconsin |
Posted:09-14-2008
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: Anthony's has really gone downhill in the past few years. I was there yesterday and I first noticed how dirty the floor was (gum stuck on carpet for example) along with the cobwebs hanging from the antiques on the wall.
We ordered a pitcher of beer and it took over 10 minutes to get that. They had to change the keg (only one other couple in the restaurant at the time besides us.
We gave our order and about15 minutes later our waiter came over to inform us that he would be right back, he had to run next door. What? He returns 10 minutes later with bags of frozen chicken from Food Lion. Then he, the cook, and another waitress stood there discussing the purchase right in front of us.
After another 20 or so minutes we finally get our food and the breaded overcooked chicken on the 'BBQ' pizza was served. It was pretty bad!! There was no BBQ sauce on the chicken, just drizzled on the pizza.
Oh, and the one waitress kept swooshing by singing to the awful music that was playing. Very Unprofessional place!
We will never eat there again.
Mytle Beach, South Carolina |
Posted:08-22-2008
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: Very disappointed in this restaurant.........we heard is was an okay place, and the food was so so but the service was absolutely horrible. We even complained to anthony, the owner, and he didn't seem the least bit bothered by our complaint. I would not recommend whatsoever.
Myrtle Beach, South Carolina |
Posted:03-05-2008
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: What a horrible place, after getting drinks we sat for a half hour watching other people get their meals, told the waitress she said "oh your order got misplaced" sat there for another 20 minutes and finally left. Dont know why we went back anyway, the previous time we went the pizza was lousy, greasy and dripping with oil, blech. They must have their friends write the reviews on here.
Towson, Maryland |
Posted:11-10-2007
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: My family loves Anthony's. We are from NY and this is the closest we have come to NY style pizza. Their entrees are very good, too. Everyhthing we have had is fresh and tastes great.
Atmosphere is a combination sports bar with alot of TV's and a pizzeria.... very casual.
Pawleys Island, South Carolina |
Posted:07-14-2007
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: We enjoyed the atmosphere and the service. The food was excellent~
Myrtle Beach, South Carolina |
Posted:04-04-2007
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: As a local group, we can suggest trying this eatery. Food is constant in quality but service varies. Although service is not a problem, when Anthony's is busy you will have to "flag down" your server as they may be covering both ends of the restaurant at the same time. If you are looking for a good, New York style pizza, this is as close as you'll find. The pasta dishes are plentiful, but the pasta is ALWAYS somewhat over-done and soft as the noodles are pre-cooked then warmed to fill an order. Asking for pasta that is more on the "chewy" side rather than the pasty side has never been complied with...any server will tell you that because pasta is pre-cooked, ALL pasta dishes come out the same way. Too bad, because the combinations of pasta dishes are almost uncountable! Definitely worth the try, but if you can avoid the dinner hour rush, you'd be better off...the wait can be VERY long and locals are not offered any special seating considerations. Pizza has a tendency to be slightly over baked so if you like your pie less cooked, let your server know in advance.
Surfside Beach, South Carolina |
Posted:02-03-2007
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: Like pizza New York style? Want it square (1/2 pie) or rectangular (rull pie). Anthony's make the best of either type, and their pasta dishes are excellent too. Try the Pizza pasta dish- amazing! Garlic knots are the best, and even a half order is plentiful. Truly great pizza, and good service. Can be noisy, but hey, shouldn't a good restaurant be full and loud?
Murrells Inlet, South Carolina |
Posted:12-19-2006
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: My wife and I are "snowbirds" and have been reading the reviews and trying out various restaurants. We have been looking for a good pizza and read all of your reviews, all favorable!
We had the small veggie pizza with adult beverage. The pizza was just as we like it, thin and the crust was cooked through not soggy or uncooked.
We are going to make this place a regular stop. We have told all of our condo residents about you. Great place.
Watertown, New York |
Posted:02-18-2006
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: Did you ever say to yourself, boy could I go for a good pizza. Well, you found it at Anthony's... it can get busy but worth the wait. Simply the best!
Lewiston, New York |
Posted:01-20-2006
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: Has the best pizza-pasta-wings on the Grand Strand. Food and service are excellent. Tony and crew do a great job!
Myrtle Beach, South Carolina |
Posted:11-15-2005
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: Upon relocating to South Carolina from New Haven, CT, we could not find a REAL Italian style pizza anywhere in this state--that is, until we found Anthony's. PERFECT pizza -- thin crust, fabulous sauce, never greasy or limp. We won't eat pizza anywhere else -- considering our families owned Italian bakeries and homemade macaroni stores in CT, that's saying something. If it weren't for Anthony's, we'd never eat pizza until we visited the northeast again.
Myrtle Beach, South Carolina |
Posted:10-10-2005
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: Stopped here for salad & Little Anthony pizza (4 slices) on Saturday afternoon and I would definitely go back again. Service was outstanding, and food was good... and they deliver!
Port Chester, New York |
Posted:10-04-2005
| Food: | |
| Service: | |
| Atmosphere: | |
| Value: | |
| Seating: | |
| Noise: | |
Review: The pasta made your way is so awesome here - I can get it exactly the way I want, with black olives, onions and tomatoes. The serving is always so big I take half of it home for the next day. My kids love the pizza.
Myrtle Beach, South Carolina |
Write a Review | Submit a Photo
|
Anthony's Pizza & Pan Pasta